Subscribe now

Letters archive

Join the conversation in New Scientist's Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


24 July 2024

We can't let the solar boom use up agricultural land

From Richard Emmett, Blacksburg, Virginia, US

You report that the boom in solar energy around the world has led to panels being installed on prime agricultural land. This is bad news, and there are many more sensible alternatives: most obviously barren desert land that can't grow food ( 6 July, p 10 ). Another option would be the roofs of buildings, …

24 July 2024

Will AI ever get to appreciate a film?

From Robert Rawlinson, Bristol, UK

Moheb Costandi writes that artificial intelligence can analyse the neuronal activity of movie watchers and identify which scenes they were observing. While this shows we can map commonality in brain activity for AIs to tap into, we lack the ability to capture the phenomenological quality of the "experience". For AIs to cross the divide into …

24 July 2024

Making air conditioning better for the planet

From Patrick Walker, Edinburgh, UK

You highlight problems with the growing demand for energy-intensive air conditioning in a warming world. How about updating building regulations so that new air conditioning installations must be accompanied by solar panels? Peak cooling demand (and electricity consumption) can be expected to correlate with daytime maximum solar radiation and maximum solar panel output ( 6 …

24 July 2024

More ways to unite world to a common purpose

From Valerie Senyk, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada

I resonated strongly with Harvey Whitehouse's point that "if we are to mature into a global tribe, capable of solving global problems, we will also need leaders capable of crossing existing tribal divisions", and that this requires "ways that are grounded in science" to address our collective interests ( 22 June, p 36 ). I …

24 July 2024

Fusion cash could have been put to better use

From Sam Edge, Ringwood, Hampshire, UK

Our climate and biodiversity woes represent a threat greater than a world war. As we would with such a conflict, we need to spend our resources wisely on projects that will reap rewards immediately, or at least within the 20 years or so we have to make the biggest impact ( 6 July, p 13 …

24 July 2024

A very cool idea, but will it be recyclable?

From Ian Gammie, St Albans, Hertfordshire, UK

The cool fabric for clothing that you describe may be rewarding for the scientists who designed it, but could it be damaging to the environment? Its three layers – wool or cotton, silver nanowires and polymethylpentene – could be a nightmare to recycle, particularly as many people wear fashionable items for a short period and …

24 July 2024

No aspect of life is totally safe, including alcohol

From James Birdwood, Shipton Moyne, Gloucestershire, UK

I take issue with Dan Roach's assertion that there is no safe level of alcohol consumption. You could equally make the case that there is no safe level of driving or playing football or swimming. Perhaps there is no safe level of being alive, given it always seems to end badly ( Letters, 6 July …

24 July 2024

Launch of the great red dot friendship campaign

From Charles Joynson, Rayleigh, Essex, UK

I have an idea related to David Robson's look at scientific rules of connection that could improve your social life. One way for pubs, parks, libraries and other social spaces to help would be to paint a large red dot on the ground. This would be a place where people who want to develop new …

24 July 2024

What we need to prove is absence of consciousness

From Graham Jones, Fochabers, Moray, UK

Recent talk of consciousness in various organisms has got me thinking. Rather than trying to investigate whether organism X has consciousness, surely a more ethical standpoint would be to assume by default that they are all conscious, so any investigation should be reversed. I suspect it would be hard to prove the absence of consciousness …

24 July 2024

Would a Dyson sphere be a monumental own goal?

From Guy Cox, Sydney, Australia

There are two problems with arguments in favour of Dyson spheres, massive structures that advanced alien species might build to capture all of a star's energy. First, long before a civilisation could build one, the issue of hydrogen fusion would have been solved and so abundant energy would be available. Second, if the aliens' star …

Issue no. 3501 published 27 July 2024

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox! We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up